According to reports, Manchester City has filed lawsuits against the Premier League for the 115 alleged rule violations.
The defending Premier League champions are reportedly contesting the legitimacy of the accusations made against them as well as the lawyer overseeing the proceedings.
The Times reports that the dispute arose because of modifications to the English top-flight’s rules, with the six-time champions of the belief that they shouldn’t apply to inquiries into suspected rule violations made before their introduction.
Read Also: Labour Party Leadership: NLC Denies Lamidi Apapa
Additionally, the club is rumoured to have contested Murray Rosen KC’s presence as an outspoken supporter of City’s title rivals Arsenal.
The Premier League’s independent judicial panel is led by the barrister Rosen, who is also permitted by the rules to nominate himself to fill the position of chairing the disciplinary commission.
Arsenal won’t have any direct input into the commission that determines what happens to City. According to a statement from the Premier League, “commissions are independent of the Premier League and member clubs.”
The lawsuit against Man City is not expected to be resolved for at least two to four years, and this most recent development is expected to make the process much more drawn out.
Manchester City first learned of the legal action over potential financial rule violations from the Premier League in February.
The club, however, made it very clear that they would use every legal means at their disposal to fight the allegations, and they asserted that they had “irrefutable evidence” to refute the alleged violations throughout the course of the previous 14 seasons.
The rules for the top flight have changed quite a bit during the last several campaigns, and it is not yet apparent which of the rule changes the challenge is aimed at.
In February 2022, the regulations were changed to require that people provide information or documentation upon request and respond to inquiries “comprehensively” and “on a cooperative and open basis.”
Further standards were changed for the 2016–17 season, stating that all teams must cooperate “fully” with Premier League inquiries and provide any information needed by the league.
The club could face a variety of potential repercussions if the allegations of alleged breaches are found to be true.
A points deduction or outright expulsion from the Premier League are possible outcomes.
The accusations against the defending champions centre on revenue-related financial information, manager and player compensation information, UEFA rules, profitability and sustainability, and cooperation with Premier League investigations.
